Productions by LGBT creators at the New Amsterdam Theater have included Her Own Way (1903) and Beau Brummell (1904-07) by Clyde Fitch; Ziegfeld Follies of 1923, with costume design by Erte and others; Betsy (1926-27), with lyrics by Lorenz Hart; Earl Carroll’s Vanities (1930-31), with costume design by Vincente Minnelli, and with actor Patsy Kelly; and Murder at the Vanities (1933) by Earl Carroll and Rufus King. LGBT performers here have included Gareth Hughes in Margaret Schiller (1916), Lilyan Tashman in Ziegfeld Follies of 1916 and 1917, Bert Savoy & Jay Brennan, a vaudeville team, in Ziegfeld Follies of 1918, Clifton Webb in Sunny (1925-26), Eva Le Gallienne, Alla Nazimova, and Josephine Hutchinson in The Cherry Orchard (revival, 1933), and Libby Holman in Revenge with Music (1934-35).
At the New Amsterdam Rooftop, Marie Dressler appeared in The Boy and the Girl (1909), and Bert Savoy & Jay Brennan were in Ziegfeld Midnight Frolic (1919) and Ziegfeld Nine O’Clock Review (1919).
It became a movie palace in 1937. Since 1997, it has been a legitimate theater for Disney productions.