One enormous hit with an LGBT performer, when this was the Forrest Theater, was Tobacco Road (1934-41), with Will Geer (opened at the Theater Masque). Another hit was Bird in Hand (1930), with Jill Esmond (opened at the Booth Theater). Anna May Wong appeared in On the Spot (1930-31), while Hand in Glove (1944-45) was directed by James Whale.
It was renamed the Coronet Theater in 1945. Despite the Wales Padlock Law (1927), which forbade the depiction of “sex perversion” on stage, and which remained on the books until 1967, one play at the Coronet was produced with a lesbian theme. This was the first revival of Lillian Hellman’s 1934 play The Children’s Hour (1952-53), about a schoolgirl who accuses two teachers of being lesbians.
Other plays here by LGBT creators and with LGBT performers included Suds in Your Eye (1944), with costume design by Kermit Love (opened at the Cort Theater); Small Wonder (1948-49), with Jack Cassidy; The Browning Version/ Harlequinade (1949) by Terence Rattigan, and with Maurice Evans; The Bird Cage (1950) by Arthur Laurents, and with Sanford Meisner; Tickets, Please! (1950), with Larry Kert; The Little Hut (1953), with scenic design by Oliver Messel; Quadrille (1954-55) by Noel Coward, with scenic and costume design by Cecil Beaton, and with actors Alfred Lunt and Lynn Fontanne; The Great Sebastians (1956), with Alfred Lunt and Lynn Fontanne; The Sleeping Prince (1956) by Terence Rattigan, and with Michael Redgrave; and The Waltz of the Toreadors (revival, 1957), with Ralph Richardson and John Abbott.
Eugene O’Neill Theater
In 1959, it was renamed the Eugene O’Neill Theater. Big hits here with LGBT associations included The Odd Couple (1966-67), with scenic design by Oliver Smith (opened at the Plymouth Theater; Best Scenic Design Tony Award); Last of the Red Hot Lovers (1969-70), with scenic design by Oliver Smith, and with James Coco; Chapter Two (1979), with scenic design by William Ritman (opened at the Imperial Theater); M. Butterfly (1988-90) with B.D. Wong (Best Featured Actor in a Play Tony Award); Grease (revival, 1994-98), with Jerry Mitchell as associate choreographer, and with actors Rosie O’Donnell and Billy Porter; and The Full Monty (2000-02) by Terrence McNally, with choreography by Jerry Mitchell, and with actors André De Shields and Denis Jones.
Other plays with LGBT creators and performers at the O’Neill included The Disenchanted (1958-59) with George Grizzard; A Loss of Roses (1959) by William Inge; A Second String (1960) based on a novel by Colette, with costume design by Robert Mackintosh; Face of a Hero (1960), with George Grizzard and Sandy Dennis; The Hostage (1960-61) by Brendan Behan (opened at the Cort Theater); Show Girl (1961), with scenic design by Oliver Smith, and costume design by Miles White; Ross (1961-62) by Terence Rattigan; A Thousand Clowns (1962-63), with Sandy Dennis; She Loves Me (1963-64), with Jack Cassidy; Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead (1968, opened at the Alvin Theater), with scenic and costume design by Desmond Heeley (Best Scenic Design and Costume Design Tony Awards); Canterbury Tales (1969), with costume design by Loudon Sainthill (Best Costume Design Tony Award), and with actor George Rose; God’s Favorite (1974-75), with scenic design by William Ritman, and with actor Charles Nelson Reilly; California Suite (1976-77), with scenic design by William Ritman, and with actor George Grizzard; Your Arms Too Short to Box with God (1977-78), with music and lyrics by Alex Bradford (opened at the Lyceum Theater); Fools (1981), with scenic design by John Lee Beatty; Little Me (revival, 1982) based on the book by Patrick Dennis (Edward Everett Tanner III), and with James Coco and Victor Garber; The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas (revival, 1982), choreographed by Tommy Tune and Thommie Walsh; The Glass Menagerie (revival 1983-84) and Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (revival, 1990) by Tennessee Williams; Penn & Teller: the Refrigerator Tour (1991), with scenic design by John Lee Beatty; and Waiting in the Wings (1999-2000) by Noel Coward with scenic design by Ray Klausen (opened at the Walter Kerr Theater).