overview

Crazy Nanny’s was a lesbian bar that drew a racially diverse crowd and was located on the ground and second floors of this building from 1991 to 2004.

The large space provided opportunity for numerous fundraisers, including those to combat the AIDS epidemic.

Header Photo
Credit: Ken Lustbader/NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project, 2019.

History

Crazy Nanny’s, open from 1991 to 2004, was located on the ground and second floors of 21 Seventh Avenue, at the corner of Leroy Street. It was run by Elaine Romagnoli, previously the owner of Cubby Hole on Hudson Street (not to be confused with Cubbyhole, a still-operating lesbian bar at 281 West 12th Street) and, for about a year, Lisa Cannistraci (the current owner of Henrietta Hudson).

Crazy Nanny’s had a large video screen, a bar on each floor, a pool table on the first floor, and dancing on the second floor. Gaia’s Guide described the space as “brightly designed,” perhaps referring to its lavender exterior. Club Planet, an online bar guide (that began to replace the hard-cover guidebooks) said of Crazy Nanny’s,

Friendly and lively, as well as casual and fashionable .… It is like a lesbian fun park, trivia night, karaoke nights, and drag queen performances and of course DJ’s.

Club Planet

The bar advertised that it was “100% women owned & 100% women managed” and that it was “a place for gay women, biological or otherwise.” The use of “biological or otherwise” was in response to neurologist Simon LeVay‘s 1991 article in Science, which stated that homosexuality was biological. This was very controversial in the gay and lesbian community at the time because many feared that this could have negative eugenic consequences.

Unlike the earlier lesbian bars, Crazy Nanny’s was more welcoming to the broader LGBT community, especially for fundraisers and special events – one event claimed that it was “an evening of Cacophony for Fags, Dykes & others.” The crowd was also racially diverse. With the larger space, Romagnoli was able to host fundraisers and performances. These ranged from live music, theater, and movie screenings, to benefits to combat AIDS as well as other causes.

Entry adapted by Amanda Davis, project manager (June 2019; last revised November 2022), from text in Gwendolyn Stegall, "A Spatial History of Lesbian Bars in New York City" (used with permission).

NOTE: Names above in bold indicate LGBT people.

Building Information

  • Architect or Builder: Unknown
  • Year Built: 1955

Sources

  1. Allison Miller, e-mail to Andrew S. Dolkart/NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project, November 22, 2022.

  2. Crazy Nanny’s,” Club Planet, accessed March 31, 2019, bit.ly/2LWRSS8.

  3. Crazy Nanny’s flyer, Lesbian Herstory Archives.

  4. Gaia’s Guide 1991/92.

  5. Gwendolyn Stegall, A Spatial History of Lesbian Bars in New York City, master’s thesis, Columbia University, May 2019.

  6. Kathy Wakeham, July 12, 2018, personal interview with Gwendolyn Stegall.

  7. The Punk Rock Fag” flyer, International Gay Information Center Ephemera – Bars, The New York Public Library.

Do you have more information about this site?

This project is enriched by your participation! Do you have your own images of this site? Or a story to share? Would you like to suggest a different historic site?

Curated Themes

26 Sites

Gay-Owned Businesses

Other Sites in the Neighborhood

56 Greenwich Avenue
Uncle Charlie’s
Bars, Clubs & Restaurants
135 & 133 West 4th Street
Washington Square United Methodist Church & Parish House
Organization & Community Spaces
Washington Place, west of Sixth Avenue
NYC Pride March
Public Spaces