Mayfair Bar & Grill, January 1952. Source: "Images of America: St. George" (2009) by David Goldfarb and James G. Ferreri.
Tax photo of 3 Hyatt Street, c. 1939. Courtesy of the NYC Municipal Archives.
By the mid-20th century, this corner building across the street from Staten Island Borough Hall was the location of a popular restaurant, known variously as the Mayfair Bar & Grill, the Mayfair Restaurant & Bar, or the Mayfair Tavern.
Based on an FBI report, the Mayfair catered to a gay crowd by the late 1950s. A 1969 guidebook created by the Mattachine Society described the restaurant as attracting a “sweater crowd” (a white-collar crowd). It also reveals that the Mayfair was “mixed” (meaning that both gay and straight people came here), though the space turned into a gay bar in the evening. During the day, it catered to people who worked in the area. According to James Hanlon, a Staten Island resident who went to the Mayfair as a college student in the early 1970s, lesbians did not typically patronize this bar and instead went to the Beach Haven in Midland Beach.
The Mayfair continued to draw gay patrons through at least the late 1970s, according to a listing in the 1978-1979 Guild Guide.
Since that time, the building has been extensively altered.
Architect or Builder: Unknown
Year Built: 1935
Guild Guide, 1978-1979, Archives of Sexuality and Gender, The New York Public Library.
James Hanlon, NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project site submission form, June 18, 2019.
New York City Gay Scene Guide, Mattachine Book Service, 1968 and 1969.
Philip Crawford, Jr., The Mafia and the Gays, self-published, 2015.
Staten Island 350th Anniversary Committee, Discovering Staten Island: A 350th Anniversary Commemorative History (Charleston: The History Press, 2011).
Do you have more information about this site?
This project is enriched by your participation! Do you have your own images of this site? Or a story to share? Would you like to suggest a different historic site?LEARN MORE