The biggest hit theater productions with LGBT associations at the Booth Theater were Bird in Hand (1929), with Jill Esmond; Blithe Spirit (1942-43) by Noel Coward, with actor Clifton Webb (opened at the Morosco Theater); Dial “M” for Murder (1954) with Maurice Evans (opened at the Plymouth Theater); Anniversary Waltz (1954-55), with costume design by Robert Mackintosh (opened at the Broadhurst Theater); The Matchmaker (1956-57) by Thornton Wilder (opened at the Royale Theater); Luv (1964-66), with scenic design by Oliver Smith (Best Scenic Design Tony Award); Butterflies Are Free (1969-72) by Leonard Gershe, with costume design by Robert Mackintosh; Sunday in the Park with George (1984-85; Pulitzer Prize for Drama), with music and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim and scenic design by Tony Straiges (Best Scenic Design Tony Award); and I’m Not Rappaport (1985-88), with lighting design by Pat Collins (Best Lighting Design Tony Award).
One lesbian-themed play attempted to open despite the Wales Padlock Law (1927), which forbade the depiction of “sex perversion” on stage. Girls in Uniform (1932) by Christa Winsloe told the story of a Prussian schoolgirl who grows attached to her teacher. It only played a dozen performances at the Booth due to the huge success of the German film version, Madchen in Uniform, that premiered before the play.
Plays with LGBT creators at the Booth Theater included Too Many Husbands (1919-20), The Breadwinner (1931), and For Services Rendered (1932) by W. Somerset Maugham; Revue Russe (1922) produced by Elisabeth Marbury; Dancing Mothers (1924-25) by Edmund Goulding and Edgar Selwyn; First Love (1926) by Zoe Akins; After All (1931) and The Distaff Side (1934-35) by John Van Druten; One for the Money (1939) and Two for the Show (1940), with scenic and costume design by Raoul Pene Du Bois, the latter with actor Richard Haydn; The Deep Mrs. Sykes (1945) by George Kelly; You Touched Me (1945-46) by Tennessee Williams and Donald Wyndham, with actor Montgomery Clift; The Would-Be Gentleman (revival, 1946), with costume design by Irene Sharaff; The Play’s the Thing (1948), with scenic design by Oliver Messel; Come Back, Little Sheba (1950) and Natural Affection (1963) by William Inge, the latter with scenic design by Oliver Smith; A Visit to a Small Planet (1957-58) by Gore Vidal, directed by Cyril Ritchard, with scenic design by Oliver Smith, with Ritchard; A Taste of Honey (1961), with production design by Oliver Smith (opened at Lyceum Theater); Tiger, Tiger Burning Bright (1962-63), with scenic design by Oliver Smith, with Alvin Ailey; The Birthday Party (1967-68), with scenic design by William Ritman; Noel Coward’s Sweet Potato (1968), with book, music and lyrics by Noel Coward, and with actor George Grizzard (opened at the Ethel Barrymore Theater); Bad Habits (1974) by Terrence McNally; All Over Town (1974-75), with scenic design by Oliver Smith, and costume design by Albert Wolsky; Mass Appeal (1981-82), with costume design by William Ivey Long; Tru (1989-90) based on the words and works of Truman Capote; Once on This Island (1990-91), with music and dance arrangements by Stephen Flaherty; The Most Happy Fella (revival, 1992), with scenic design by John Lee Beatty; An Evening with Jerry Herman (1998), with music and lyrics by Jerry Herman, with Herman and Lee Roy Reams; Via Dolorosa (1999), with scenic and costume design by Ian MacNeil; and The Search for Signs of Intelligent Life in the Universe (revival, 2000-01) by Jane Wagner, with Lily Tomlin.
LGBT performers at the Booth have included Guthrie McClintic in The Great Adventure (1913), Eugene O’Brien in The Money Makers (1914), Harrison Ford in The Bubble (1915), Eva Le Gallienne in Not So Long Ago (1920), Blythe Daly in Happy-Go-Lucky (1920), Charles Laughton in The Fatal Alibi (1932), Spring Byington in The First Apple (1933-34), Montgomery Clift in Dame Nature (1938) and Foxhole in the Parlor (1945), John Abbott in his Broadway debut in He Who Gets Slapped (1946), Edward Everett Horton in Springtime for Henry (1951) (opened at Golden Theater), An Evening with Beatrice Lillie (1952-53) starring Beatrice Lillie, Michael Feinstein in Isn’t It Romantic (1988), Alec McCowen in Someone Who’ll Watch Over Me (1992-93), and Sandra Bernhard in I’m Still Here… Damn It! (1998-99).