Opened as the Theatre Republic in 1900, this venue staged two known works by gay playwrights, one by Clyde Fitch and the other by Roi Cooper Megrue.

After being converted to burlesque in 1931 and a movie theater in 1942, it reopened as the New Victory Theater in 1995.

Header Photo
Credit: Sarah Sargent/NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project, 2019.


This venue, the oldest surviving Broadway theater, was originally known as the Theatre Republic. There were two known plays by gay playwrights at this theater, both rather successful: Lover’s Lane (1901) by Clyde Fitch (opened at the Manhattan Theater), and Where Poppies Bloom (1918) by Roi Cooper Megrue.

In 1931, it was converted to burlesque, then in 1942 to movies. The theater was restored and reopened in 1995 as the New Victory Theater for family-oriented fare.

Building Information

  • Architect or Builder: Albert Westover
  • Year Built: 1900


  1. Internet Broadway Database.

Curated Themes

43 Sites

Broadway Theater District

Other Sites in the Neighborhood

219 West 48th Street
Walter Kerr Theater (originally Ritz Theater)
Performance Venues
150 West 55th Street
Carl Van Vechten Residence
234-240 West 45th Street
Gerald Schoenfeld Theater (originally Plymouth Theater)
Performance Venues