Opened in 1903, the Lyric Theater staged several productions involving major LGBT performers and creators, including Clyde Fitch, Cole Porter, and Sarah Bernhardt, among others, before becoming a movie theater in 1934 (the historic interior was demolished in 1996).
The Mattachine Society of New York, an early gay rights group, held its meetings at Avlon Studios in this building from 1956-57, shortly after forming in December 1955.
Credit: Sarah Sargent/NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project, 2019.
Harrison Ford, actor in Glorious Betsy, n.d. Source unknown.
The City by Clyde Fitch, 1909. Source: flipkart.com.
Edward Everett Horton, actor in The Cheater, n.d. Source unknown.
Rachel Crothers, playwright of Ourselves. Photo by Paul Thompson, c. 1917. Courtesy of the Museum of the City of New York.
Playbill cover for Fifty Million Frenchmen, 1929.
The 43rd Street facade of the Lyric Theater.
The Lyric Theater had several hits by gay playwrights and composers: The Blue Mouse (1908-09) and The City (1909-10) by Clyde Fitch; Abe and Mawruss (1915-16) by Montague Glass and Roi Cooper Megrue; and Fifty Million Frenchmen (1929-30), directed by Monty Woolley, with music and lyrics by Cole Porter. Ourselves (1913) by Rachel Crothers was also performed here.
LGBT performers at the Lyric included Sarah Bernhardt (1906), Harrison Ford in Glorious Betsy (1908), Laurette Taylor in The Great John Ganton (1909), and Edward Everett Horton in The Cheater (1910).
In 1934 legitimate theater ended here and it became a movie theater. The historic theater interior was demolished in 1996.
The Mattachine Society of New York was founded in the apartment of Sam Morford at 16 East 8th Street in Greenwich Village in December 1955 with five members, and had its first general meeting at the Diplomat Hotel (demolished) in January 1956. Monthly meetings were then held at Avlon Studios in this theater building until 1957.